OPride
Friday May 25, 2018
by Zecharias Zelalem
(OPride)—A tall, sharply dressed man with warm, reassuring smile
walked toward me and shook my hands. It’s a firm but friendly handshake.
For a moment I thought he’s a brother or cousin of Bashir Makhtal, a
Canadian citizen who spent more than 11 years in Ethiopia’s notorious
prisons on bogus terrorism charges.
For someone who spent the last decade languishing in maximum security
prisons — being shifted in and out of solitary confinement where he
endured brutal torture —Bashir looks incredibly well.
It’s only been a month since Bashir walked free from the infamous
Maekelawi prison in Addis Ababa. He was convicted on terrorism charges
and accused of being a member of the outlawed rebel group, Ogaden
National Liberation Front (ONLF). He denies the charges. He was
sentenced to life in prison in 2009 in a trial deemed sham by rights
groups.
Days after he was freed, Bashir flew to Canada and was welcomed home
at Toronto airport in an emotional reunion with his family. On Tuesday
when I met him in Ottawa, he had just hosted a press conference and was
waiting for the start of a meeting organized by Amnesty International,
the rights group that took up his cause a decade ago. Seamlessly
transitioning between events, Bashir appears upbeat and content. The
trauma and scars of his eleven years of torment weren’t visible at least
on the surface.
He ushered me into a conference room of Amnesty International’s
Canadian headquarters, where his wife Aziza and cousin, Said Makhtal,
were waiting. I recognized Said immediately. During the entirety of
Bashir’s ordeal, Said was the public face of the campaign to free his
cousin. He has made plenty of media appearances over the past decade in
which he urged the Canadian government to pressure Ethiopian authorities
to release Bashir.
Despite the psychological and financial toll they have endured, both Said and Aziza looked remarkably well and still elated.
Bashir speaks with a soft tone. He has an easy-going demeanor. He
didn’t hesitate to delve into the horrific and tragic injustices that
shaped the last decade of his life.
OPride: First off, on behalf of our readers and staff, I am glad
that you are with your family and that your nightmare is over. Welcome
back to Canada. We’d also like to thank you for willing to share your
story with us.
Bashir: Thank you very much. I’m thankful you are
here, as there are a lot of things I need to share with Ethiopians, with
the world about my case and about what happens in Ethiopia.
OPride: Most of us heard of your plight as a Canadian citizen
fighting a politically motivated sentence. But there are many who are
eager to get to know you better. Tell us about your upbringing. Where
does the Bashir Makhtal story begin?
Bashir: I was born in the town of Deghabour,
Ethiopia. I lived there until the age of six. As I’m sure you know, the
people of my region, the Ogaden, have faced systematic oppression at the
hands of different Ethiopian governments. My family fled this
oppression for neighboring Somalia and I grew up and went to school in
the capital Mogadishu. I had a normal childhood.
OPride: Years later, when you were accused by an Ethiopian court of
being an ONLF fighter, Ethiopian government media pointed to the fact
that your grandfather, Makhtal Dahir, was the founder of the ONLF. As a
child growing up, did you see much of Makhtal Dahir? Did he influence
you in any way?
Bashir: It’s true that I’m the grandson of Makhtal
Dahir, the founding chairman of the ONLF. He was a great leader and
fighter for the cause of the Ogaden people. Somalis have suffered
unbearably under the Ethiopian imperial and then military dictatorships.
My grandfather fought to secure basic rights for his people — nothing
else. He was among the first to launch a revolt against the system that
was killing his people. We know his history very well, but I saw none of
this as a child as he had become old and had ceased participation in
these sorts of activities. For example, he was uncompromising on the
ONLF agenda and opposed the initiative of the WSLF (Western Somali
Liberation Front) because that group had the goal of incorporating our
region into Somalia. The ONLF pursued independence from Ethiopia and an
end to the persecution of our people. My grandfather and his colleagues
didn’t like the idea of the demarcated Ogaden territory being absorbed
into Somalia. My grandfather’s story is well known, but as I said most
of it happened before I was born so I wasn’t a witness to it.
OPride: I understand you immigrated to Canada as a young man. Tell us about your life here in Canada prior to your arrest.
Bashir: Yes, I actually went to Italy first. My
elder brother was already in Canada and his presence here influenced my
decision to come to immigrate to Canada. I arrived in 1991. I lived in
the Toronto area and pursued my education, studying Computer Science at
DeVry University. I worked hard for my goals and my degrees. I
eventually got a job in my domain at the CIBC (Canadian Imperial Bank of
Commerce).
OPride: You became a Canadian citizen and after hard work and
tribulations; entered the professional job market and started giving
back to society. Then, in 2001, 10 years after you arrived in Canada,
you decided to return to East Africa. What was the reason for your trip?
Bashir: I had a good life and a decent job in
Canada. But I had intended on providing for not just myself, but my
family members. I have around 20 siblings. On my salary, my
contributions to them were limited. I was looking for options when a
friend of mine — a fellow Somali and also a Canadian citizen — came to
me with a proposal. He told me there was a market for selling used
clothes in the region that would be very profitable. His business plan
seemed foolproof and we became partners. So we left Canada with an idea.
I was based in Djibouti, but we operated in Somalia, Djibouti and the
United Arab Emirates. Business was good. I provided for my family and
traveled frequently between these three countries. From 2001 until my
arrest [in December 2006], I lived a successful life as a businessman.
OPride: The main charge against you was that you were an ONLF member
and it is linked to this period of your life. The Ethiopian government
has always maintained that during this time, you made a trip to Eritrea
that was not for business reasons. Eritrea has a history of supporting
the ONLF. Did you ever travel to Eritrea and if so, what were the
reasons for doing so?
Bashir: It is true that I traveled to Eritrea on two
occasions. I never claimed to have traveled to Eritrea for business
reasons. I will make this part clear to you. Sometime before 2004, the
ONLF held a general assembly in London where they published a communique
which had information about the organization’s goals and details about
its leadership. I have never been involved with the ONLF in any shape,
way or form. Yet, to my surprise, I found my name listed among those as
members of the group’s leadership team. Not only me, other notable
Somalis also found themselves on this list. The ONLF politburo members
knew my identity as a grandson of Makhtal Dahir and a member of the
Somali community. But they never consulted me on the inclusion of my
name among members of the organization. So I contacted them and
requested the removal of my name.
I was told that I have to appear before a committee in person in
order for my request to be processed. This is the reason for my first
trip. The said committee was at the time-based in Asmara, Eritrea. So in
2004, I traveled to Asmara for the first time to meet with ONLF
representatives. When I got there, I was told that some key officials
weren’t present for various reasons and that I wouldn’t be able to get
my name removed. I had to wait for another occasion. I stayed in Eritrea
for two days and left. In early 2006, the ONLF had another meeting. I
went back to Eritrea to clear my name. This time, they heard me out.
I left Asmara having been told that my request will be processed.
Sure enough, in June of that year, I received two notices from the
organization. One was the newly published list of ONLF leaders with my
name removed from the list. The second was an official letter from the
ONLF leadership apologizing to me for any inconveniences caused. I
received these in June of 2006, and as you know, I was arrested six
months later. I have never been a member of the ONLF. I had these
documents in Canada. I managed to get them faxed to Ethiopia. Both
documents, including the ONLF’s official apology, were submitted to the
judge as evidence of my innocence during my trial. I think they were
never even taken into consideration.
OPride: Let’s rewind a bit and look at the events leading up to your
arrest. The narrative long held by the Ethiopian court that sentenced
you is that you were taken into custody by Kenyan troops on the Somali
border after having fought with militants in Somalia. This was during
the first weeks of the Ethiopian army’s December 2006 invasion of
Somalia. What led you to being caught on the Kenyan Somali border?
Bashir: Well, as I stated earlier, I was a
businessman who frequented Mogadishu regularly. I was in the capital
during those last few days before the Ethiopian army took over. At the
time, the Ethiopian government was explaining to the whole world that
everyone — the Islamists, the ONLF, the Oromo Liberation Front (OLF) and
others — were all in Somalia planning to launch attacks against
Ethiopia. This is all a fabrication. But it became clear that they would
use this as a pretext to invade the country. I realized that the
situation had become unstable and that with the Ethiopian soldiers
coming, it would be too dangerous to remain in Somalia. So I tried to
book my flight out. What many don’t know is that in those last days
before the invasion, the Ethiopian government planned every detail.
Together, Ethiopia, with the help of the U.S. government and the
so-called Somali Transitional Government sealed the country’s airspace.
There were no flights allowed in and out of Somalia. There was no way
out of the country. I had planned on flying out to Dubai but was unable
to. I waited a few days and then I realized that I if I stayed any
longer, I could be caught up in a war. So that’s when I decided to
travel by land out of Mogadishu. I rented a car and was driven to the
Kenyan border. From there, I crossed the border into Kenya and traveled
to Garissa [northeastern Kenya), where there was an immigration office. I
planned on applying for a visa there which I could use to stay in Kenya
for a few days, enough time to travel to Nairobi and book a flight back
to Djibouti. Many other foreigners were already there. With no flights
out of Somalia, they were left stranded and took this same route to
Garissa.
OPride: So you weren’t actually captured on the border by Kenyan
soldiers as was widely reported. You made your way peacefully to
Garissa.
Bashir: That’s right. At Garissa’s immigration
office, we had to undergo screening. Kenyan authorities were wary of
militants infiltrating the country, so they took their time with us. I
was held there for five days, as they looked at my documents and file.
After five days, they told me I was in the clear. They would transfer me
to Nairobi. Everything seemed routine so far. On the sixth day, I was
taken to a police station in Nairobi. Coincidentally, this police
station is located next to the Canadian embassy. I expected my wait in
that police officer to be the end of it. But I remained there for weeks.
There were a number of other foreigners with me and we each waited for
our turns, but my wait was the longest. While I was there, two Ethiopian
intelligence agents came to the station and started observing me from
close range. They chatted with the Kenyan police officials and would
come back and sit with us. I felt something was fishy.
OPride: How did you know that they were, in fact, Ethiopian
intelligence officers? Did they have any clothing or visible markers
that gave away their identities?
Bashir: No they were plainclothes officers. I grew
suspicious of them because they appeared out of nowhere and they
immediately concentrated on me. I asked them “who are you?” One of them
told me, “I’m a foreigner stranded like you.” I didn’t believe him. I’ve
lived around East Africans all my life. We know each other’s traits
very well. I identified them as being Tigrayans just by looking at them.
Then my suspicion grew into fear when one of them asked if he could
videotape me. I objected. At this time, I had enough. I contacted a
friend in Nairobi. He came to the police station and gave me a cellular
phone. I knew that I could always be a target of harassment and
intimidation by the Ethiopian government, so I used the phone to notify
the Canadian embassy of my circumstances. I was wary of what would
happen next.
OPride: So the first contact between Ethiopian and Kenyan security forces happened in Nairobi?
Bashir: Yes. Both cooperated to ensure that I was
transferred to Ethiopian custody. I have insider information that this
was a personal request by [the late] Prime Minister Meles Zenawi, who
went as far as promising the Kenyan leader at the time (Mwai) Kibaki
millions of dollars for his reelection campaign as a gift for handing me
over to Ethiopian authorities. I didn’t know this at the time. From the
police station, we were taken in vehicles to Jomo Kenyatta
International Airport. As foreign nationals, we were told we would be
deported back to our countries.
Aboard the vehicle, people chatted and talked, so nobody noticed me
make a last phone call. I called my wife [in Canada] and told her I felt
uncertain about what was happening to me. At the airport, there were
state journalists and Kenyan security officials. They wanted to report
on the story that foreigners fleeing Somalia were returning home. I,
along with a group of foreigners, was separated from the rest and taken
to the cargo section of the airport.
I noticed the plane on the runway that we were supposed to board.
Having flown back and forth across the region, I could identify the
plane models and the locations they would fly to. The rather small plane
was one used to fly from Nairobi to Mogadishu. It wasn’t what was used
for intercontinental flights. Why would they send me to Somalia? I went
up to a Kenyan security officer and asked: “Excuse me, if I’m being
deported, as a Canadian, shouldn’t I be deported to my country?”
The Kenyan security officer laughed at me and told me in a mocking
tone, “yeah we will send you to your country.” When it was time to
board, I refused. I refused to move and when they started to physically
force me on the plane, I screamed out loud. I created a scene. When they
saw that I wouldn’t go willingly, Kenyan soldiers came over to me and
severely beat me. I boarded the plane bloodied. The attack on me
dislocated my shoulder and left me in searing pain. I felt the pain in
my shoulder for the next two years. The plane departed for Somalia. By
that time, the Ethiopian army was already in the capital, Mogadishu.
From there, I was put on an Ethiopian military plane and flown into
Addis Ababa on January 16, 2007.
OPride: You were physically assaulted at Jomo Kenyatta International
Airport. Despite neither being born in Somalia nor being a citizen of
that country, you were deported there — which is an extraordinary
rendition and thus against international law. There were a host of
violations of your rights even before entering Ethiopian custody. At the
time, it was reported that you had acquired the services of a lawyer by
the name of Mekuria Tafesse. Did this lawyer ever manage to speak of
these violations to the judge?
Bashir: I have never met this Mekuria Tafesse. He
was hired by my family and the Canadian embassy to defend me. I had no
access to any lawyers during the first 18 months of my incarceration.
Mr. Mekuria was given a lot of money, I’m not sure how much exactly but I
can find out for you. He never once met with me, and, in the end, he
left the job before I had made a single court appearance –making a hefty
sum and doing absolutely nothing for me. I had another lawyer,
Gebreamlak Tekle who was appointed just as my trial was set to begin. He
is the one who presented the judge with the ONLF apology document that
should have cleared me. But this case wasn’t about evidence. It was
completely fabricated from beginning to end.
OPride: What part of the case against you do you think was fabricated?
Bashir: My trial began in August 2008. I knew I was
innocent and had nothing to hide. I even waved my right to not be
cross-examined. But then the eyewitnesses began to testify. One came out
and said under oath that I was an ONLF commander who he had seen
fighting in Somalia. But the second witness had the most ridiculous
testimony. He told the court that he had seen me among the ONLF fighters
who carried out the attack on the Abole oil field in the Ogaden. It was
the attack that left many Ethiopian and Chinese oil workers dead. That
incident happened in April 2007. I was detained in December 2006. How
could I carry out an attack and kill oil workers in the Ogaden if I was
imprisoned at Maekelawi? I had been incarcerated for four months when
this attack took place. When I heard this false testimony, I knew that
the whole court process was corrupted. Later on, I discovered that some
of those who testified against me had signed a written affidavit,
declaring that everything they said in court was untrue. It was all
fake. It was planned. They wanted me to suffer. They stole me from my
wife and family.
This interview was lightly edited for clarity. In Part II, Bashir
talks about his time in prison, the people he met and the injustices
he’d witnessed, as well as his release. Check back soon.